El Herradero Mexican Grill Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to El Herradero Mexican Grill, a vibrant dining spot in Urbana, Ohio, where the flavors of Mexico come alive! This lively restaurant offers a diverse range of dishes, perfect for seafood lovers, salad aficionados, and traditional Mexican fare fans alike.

The menu shines with an array of dinner combos, featuring enticing options like the Taco, Enchilada, and Chalupa Combo, each priced at an incredible $13.99. For a fresh twist, don’t miss the Fajita Taco Salad or the delightful Shrimp Fajita Taco Salad, which showcases beautifully grilled shrimp and a medley of vegetables.

Start your meal with the Sampler El Herradero, an indulgent feast perfect for sharing. Whether you're dining in or opting for takeout, the restaurant promises a memorable culinary experience that captures the essence of authentic Mexican cuisine.

Dinner Combos

Taco, Enchilada and Chalupa Combo

$13.99

Taco, Enchilada and Chile Relleno Combo

$13.99

2 Tacos, Enchilada and Chile con Carne Combo

$13.99

Taco, 2 Enchiladas and Mexican Rice Combo

$13.99

Chalupa, Chile Relleno and Refried Beans Combo

$13.99

Taco, Enchilada and Burrito Combo

$13.99

2 Tacos, Mexican Rice and Refried Beans Combo

$13.99

Enchilada, Chalupa and Mexican Rice Combo

$13.99

Enchilada, Tamale, Mexican Rice and Refried Beans Combo

$13.99

Enchilada, Chile Relleno, Rice and Beans Combo

$13.99

Enchilada, Taco, Rice and Beans Combo

$13.99

2 Enchiladas, Mexican Rice and Refried Beans Combo

$13.99

Quesadilla, Burrito and Rice Combo

$13.99

Beef Burrito, Enchilada and Tamale Combo

$13.99

Chalupa, Chile Relleno and Taco Combo

$13.99

Chalupa, Chile Relleno and Enchilada Combo

$13.99

Chalupa, Chile Relleno and Burrito Combo

$13.99

Enchilada, Burrito, Mexican Rice and Refried Beans Combo

$13.99

Enchilada, Chalupa and Burrito Combo

$13.99

Chalupa, Taco and Tostada Combo

$13.99

Chile Relleno, Burrito and Mexican Rice Combo

$13.99

Chile Relleno, Taco, Mexican Rice and Refried Beans Combo

$13.99

Burrito, Taco and Chalupa Combo

$13.99

Burrito, Taco and Chile Relleno Combo

$13.99

Burrito, Taco, Mexican Rice and Refried Beans Combo

$13.99

Two Burritos, Mexican Rice and Refried Beans Combo

$13.99

Burrito, Tamale, Mexican Rice and Refried Beans Combo

$13.99

Tostada, Enchilada, Mexican Rice and Refried Beans Combo

$13.99

Taco, Tamale and Burrito Combo

$13.99

Tostaguac, Chile Relleno and Mexican Rice Combo

$13.99

Sampler El Herradero

A family-sized combination of one chimichanga, four slices of quesadilla and two taquitos - all filled with your choice of beef or chicken. Served with lettuce, guacamole and sour cream.

$17.99

Nachos with Cheese and Beans

Chips with cheese and a variety of toppings.

$7.99

Nachos with Beef

Chips with cheese and a variety of toppings.

$8.99

Nachos with Beef, Beans and Cheese

Chips with cheese and a variety of toppings.

$9.99

Nachos with Chicken

Chips with cheese and a variety of toppings.

$8.99

Nachos Supremos

Tortilla chips covered with a melted cheese blend, beef, chicken and refried beans, all covered with lettuce, tomato and sour cream.

$13.99

Appetizers

Salads

Grilled Chicken Salad

Served with lettuce, tomato and shredded cheese.

$11.99

Steak Salad

Served with lettuce, tomato and shredded cheese.

$11.99

Fajita Taco Salad

A crispy-fried taco shell filled with beans, lettuce, cheese, tomato, sour cream, guacamole and your choice of steak or chicken.

$13.99

Shrimp Fajita Taco Salad

Shrimp cooked with bell pepper, onion and tomato inside a crispy taco shell topped with lettuce, tomato, sour cream and guacamole.

$15.99

Taco Salad

A crispy flour tortilla with guacamole, sour cream and your choice of beef or chicken cooked with peppers, onion and tomato.

$11.99

Guacamole Salad

A fresh salad with an avocado base.

$6.99

Tossed Salad

Salad that has been tossed with dressing.

$4.99

Fajita Quesadilla

Filled with cheese and choice of steak or chicken with tomato, onion and bell pepper, topped with cheese sauce and served with Spanish rice and refried beans.

$14.99

Quesadilla Tapatia

One quesadilla filled with cheese, chicken and Mexican chorizo. Served with Spanish rice, lettuce, tomato and sour cream. Garnished with a slice of pineapple.

$14.99

Quesadilla Suprema

A flour tortilla stuffed with your choice of beef or chicken and refried beans. Served with lettuce, tomato and sour cream.

$13.99

Quesadilla Espinacas

A flour tortilla stuffed with cheese and spinach. Served with rice and beans.

$13.99

Quesadilla Rapida

Filled with shredded chicken or beef and topped with cheese sauce. Served with rice and beans.

$13.99

Quesadilla Vegetariana

A flour tortilla stuffed with cheese, zucchini and spinach. Served with rice and beans.

$13.99

Quesadilla quatro caminos

One chicken and one ground beef cut into 4pieces. Topped with cheese sauce. Served with lettuce, pico de gallo, sour cream.

$13.99

Quesadillas

Burritos

Burrito Diablo Verde

Filled with grilled steak, rice, jalapenos and beans, topped with verde salsa and cheese dip.

$16.99

Burrito Mariachi

Stuffed with choice of beef or chicken cooked with bell pepper, tomato and onion. Topped with lettuce, tomato, sour cream and cheese. Served with Spanish rice and refried beans.

$13.99

Burrito California

It's the big one. A flour tortilla stuffed with choice of steak or chicken, bell pepper and onion. Served with lettuce, tomato, guacamole, Spanish rice and refried beans. Covered with cheese sauce and mild red sauce.

$16.99

Burrito Deluxe

Two burritos, one chicken and bean and one beef and bean, topped with lettuce, tomato and sour cream.

$14.99

Spicy Burrito

A large flour tortilla stuffed with steak or chicken cooked with tomato, onion and bell pepper, then topped with cheese dip, lettuce, tomato and sour cream. Served with rice and beans.

$15.99

Burritos de Carne Asada

Two burritos filled with tender grilled steak and topped with our special salsa verde and cheese dip. served with refried beans.

$16.99

Fajita Burrito

A large flour tortilla filled with steak or chicken cooked with tomato, onion and bell pepper, then topped with cheese sauce. Served with sour cream, lettuce, pico de gallo and choice of Spanish rice or refried beans.

$15.99

Burrito Grande

One big burrito stuffed with choice of steak or chicken, Spanish rice, refried beans and nacho sauce. Served with sour cream and pico de gallo.

$16.99

Enchiladas Verdes

3 chicken enchiladas with our special green sauce and cheese dip. served with lettuce, tomato and rice.

$13.99

Enchilada Suprema

One chicken, one refried bean, one cheese and one beef enchilada all topped with cheese, lettuce, tomato and sour cream.

$13.99

Enchiladas Tapatias

3 chicken enchiladas with choice of chicken or beef tips topped with enchilada sauce and shredded cheese. Served with Spanish rice and refried beans.

$13.99

Enchiladas Rancheras

2 cheese enchiladas topped with enchilada sauce and pork cooked with tomatoes, onions and peppers. Served with lettuce, tomato and sour cream.

$13.99

Yolandas

3 chicken enchiladas topped with cheese and ranchero sauce, sour cream and tomato. Served with Spanish rice.

$13.99

Enchiladas

Fajitas

Chicken Fajitas

$15.99

Steak Fajitas

$16.99

Fajitas Supremas

Tender sliced steak, chicken and shrimp.

$19.99

Pina Fajita

Chicken, chorizo and pineapple chunks.

$19.99

El Molcajete

Served with strips of fajita steak grilled with shrimp, mushrooms, poblano peppers, onion, chorizo and our special sauce, served with mozzarella cheese and tortillas.

$19.99

Molcajete Loco

Thin-sliced grilled steak and chicken with shrimp, chorizo and onion topped with grilled jalapenos. Served with rice, beans, pico de gallo, guacamole and flour tortillas.

$24.99

Shrimp Fajitas

$20.99

Fajita Herradero

Served with tender strips of steak and chicken.

$18.99

Fajita Parrilla

Steak, chicken, chorizo and shrimp with shredded cheese.

$21.99

Fajita Loca

Served with shrimp, chicken, zucchini and onion, all topped with cheese.

$20.99

Chimichanga

One chimichanga filled with your choice of beef or chicken, topped with cheese dip, lettuce, tomato, sour cream and guacamole. Served with rice and refried beans.

$12.99

Chimichangas Charras

2 chimichangas, one beef and one chicken topped with cheese dip and served with lettuce, guacamole, tomato and rice.

$14.99

Grilled Chimichanga

A crispy flour tortilla filled with tender grilled chicken or steak with nacho cheese sauce. Served with a guacamole salad, sour cream, rice and refried beans.

$15.99

Chimichangas Piquas

2 crispy flour tortillas filled with your choice of ground beef or shredded chicken and topped with red sauce and cheese dip. served with rice and beans.

$15.99

Chimichangas

Vegetarian Combos

A. Chalupa, Cheese Enchilada and Rice Combo

$12.99

B. 2 Bean Burritos Combo

Topped with nacho cheese and burrito sauce.

$12.99

C. Bean Burrito, Cheese Enchilada and Bean Tostada Combo

$12.99

D. Bean Burrito, Quesadilla and Chalupa Combo

$12.99

Spinach Quesadilla

A grilled flour tortilla filled with cheese and spinach, topped with cheese sauce and served with rice and beans.

$12.99

Pollo Bandido

Grilled chicken topped with cheese dip and served with rice, beans and tortillas.

$14.99

Chicken a la Crema

Slices of grilled chicken breast topped with sliced poblano peppers and sour cream sauce. Served with Spanish rice, lettuce, tomato and guacamole salad.

$16.99

Popeye's Chicken

Grilled chicken breast topped with spinach and cheese dip, served with rice, beans and tortillas.

$16.99

El Tapatio

Grilled chicken breast and Mexican sausage topped with melted cheese. Served with Spanish rice, lettuce, tomato and guacamole.

$18.99

Pollo a la Vallarta

Grilled chicken breast and shrimp cooked with mushrooms and topped with cheese sauce. Served with Spanish rice, sour cream, lettuce, tomato and tortillas.

$20.99

Jalisco Special

Strips of marinated chicken breast with shrimp and Spanish rice, topped with cheese sauce.

$16.99

Choripollo

Grilled chicken breast topped with chorizo and cheese sauce. Served with Spanish rice.

$16.99

Pollo Loco

Grilled chicken breast topped with cheese dip and served with rice, guacamole salad and tortillas.

$15.99

Chicken

Steak

Carne Asada

Thin sliced, marinated steak grilled with green onions and served with rice, beans, guacamole, pico de gallo and flour tortillas.

$17.99

Vaca Bandida

Grilled steak topped with cheese dip and served with rice, beans and tortillas.

$14.99

Monterrey Cheese Steak

A soft tortilla filled with sliced steak, grilled onion and nacho cheese sauce. Served with lettuce, tomato and choice of spanish rice or refried beans.

$15.99

Steak a la Mexicana

A 12 oz. t-bone steak with grilled onion bell pepper and tomato. Served with Spanish rice, beans and tortillas.

$18.99

Steak and Shrimp

A juicy 10 oz. steak with shrimp, sauteed onion, tomato and mushrooms topped with cheese sauce. Served with rice and tortillas.

$18.99

Zarape Special

Steak cooked with pico de gallo, topped with cheese sauce and served with rice and beans.

$13.99

Alambres

Pieces of ribeye steak with onion, tomato and peppers topped with cheese sauce. Served with Spanish rice, refried beans and tortillas.

$18.99

Chile Colorado

Grilled steak cooked with ranchero sauce and served with Spanish rice, refried beans and flour tortillas.

$16.99

Chile Verde

Shredded carnitas topped with green salsa and cheese sauce. Served with rice, beans and flour tortillas.

$15.99

Shrimp Enchiladas

3 enchiladas filled with shrimp and topped with our special green sauce and cheese dip. Served with spanish rice, lettuce, tomato and sour cream.

$16.99

Fish Tacos

3 fish tacos with rice, beans, pico de gallo and green sauce.

$15.99

Shrimp Chimichanga

One chimichanga stuffed with shrimp and cheese sauce, covered with lettuce, tomato, sour cream and guacamole. Served with refried beans.

$17.99

Tilapia Veracruz

Grilled tilapia fillet plated with shrimp, grilled zucchini and spinach. Served with rice and warm tortillas.

$19.99

Camarones a la Diabla

Shrimp cooked with our spicy salsa diablo. Served with Spanish rice, guacamole salad and tortillas.

$18.99

Quesadilla de Camaron

A flour tortilla stuffed with shrimp and cheese, served with Spanish rice and beans.

$16.99

Coctel de Camaron

Large shrimp cooked with lime juice and served in our special recipe cocktail sauce with avocado and pico de gallo.

$17.99

Tilapia

A grilled tilapia fillet cooked with onion, tomato and bell pepper. Served with rice, beans and tortillas.

$15.99

Seafood

Specialties

Herradero Special

A little bit of everything. One chalupa, one chile relleno, one taco, one enchilada and one tamal. Served with Spanish rice and refried beans.

$19.99

Chiles Rellenos Special

2 poblano peppers stuffed with potato and cheese, topped with our special red sauce and served with Spanish rice and refried beans.

$14.99

Taquitos Mexicanos Special

3 fried taquitos filled with choice of beef or chicken and served with Mexican rice, refried beans, lettuce, tomato and sour cream.

$13.99

Carnitas de Puerco Special

Fried pork tips served with Spanish rice, refried beans, tortillas and pico de gallo.

$15.99

Quesadillas Chicken

$6.99

Quesadillas Beef

$6.99

Steak quesadilla

$7.99

Grilled Chicken

$7.99

Cheese quesadilla

$4.99

Burritos Bean

$4.99

Burritos Beef

$6.99

Burritos Chicken

$6.99

Enchiladas

$4.99

Tamale

$5.99

Beef Tacos

$3.50

Beef Soft Tacos

$3.50

Chicken Tacos

$3.50

Chicken Soft Tacos

$3.50

Chalupa

$4.99

Tostada

$5.99

Chile Relleno

$5.99

A la Carte

Fiesta Dips

Queso Fundido

Mexican chorizo and cheese dip served with corn tortillas.

$7.99

Cheese Dip

$4.99

Pico de Gallo

$3.99

Bean Dip

$6.99

Guacamole

$4.99

Cheese Rice

$4.99

French Fries

$3.99

Sour Cream

$1.99

Tomatoes

$1.50

Shredded Cheese

$2.50

Flour Tortilla

$1.50

Mushrooms

$3.50

Jalapenos

$1.99

Rice

$3.50

Beans

$3.50

Shrimp

$9.99

Chips to Go

$2.99

Salsa to Go

16 oz.

$5.99

Sides

Ninos

Corn dog

Served with fries

$7.99

Kids Chicken Nuggets

Served with fries.

$7.99

Kids Cheese Quesadilla

Served with rice and beans.

$6.99

Kids Taco

Served with rice and beans.

$6.99

Kids Burrito

Served with rice and beans.

$6.99

Kids Cheeseburger

Served with fries.

$7.99

Kids Enchilada

Served with rice and beans.

$6.99

Kids Hot Dog

Served with fries.

$7.99

Pepperoni pizza

Served with fries

$8.99

Speedy Gonzalez

One taco, one enchilada and choice of rice or refried beans.

$7.99

Huevos con Chorizo

Eggs scrambled with Mexican sausage and served with rice and beans.

$8.99

Beef Burrito

Served with Spanish rice and refried beans.

$7.99

Super Burrito

One burrito filled with choice of beef or chicken and topped with cheese, lettuce, tomato and sour cream.

$7.99

Burrito and Taco

Served with Spanish rice.

$8.99

Lunch Chimichanga

One flour tortilla filled with chicken or beef and topped with cheese sauce, lettuce, tomato, sour cream and guacamole. Served with Spanish rice and refried beans.

$8.99

Chile Verde Burrito

Filled with pieces of tender pork topped with green sauce. Served with Spanish rice and refried beans.

$11.99

Beef Enchilada

Served with lettuce, tomato, sour cream, Spanish rice and refried beans.

$7.99

Fajita Lunch Special

Choice of chicken or steak served with Spanish rice, beans, guacamole salad and a side of tortillas.

$11.99

Taquitos Mexicanos

Three taquitos, choice of chicken or beef. Served with Spanish rice and salad.

$8.99

Monterrey Cheesesteak

A soft flour tortilla filled with thin-sliced steak, grilled onion and nacho cheese sauce. Served with lettuce, tomato and your choice of Spanish rice and refried beans.

$10.99

Lunch

Beverages

Soft Drinks

$2.99

Iced Tea

$2.99

Milk

$2.99

Chocolate Milk

$2.99